Alternative Rock Review 

 Essential Album Series

Essential Rock Albums: 1998

Essential Albums Index

Hall Of Fame

The Noughties

The Nineties

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

The Eighties

The Seventies

The Sixties

rformance comparison. Nvidia GeForce2 MX 400, 200, 100, review.

1 Massive Attack - 'Mezzanine' (Virgin)
 
The shadowy overlords of trip-hop fulfill their potential with a dark, sexy and menacing record of tight grooves, inspired guest appearances and a soundtrack to late night driving music. The fragile beauty of 'Teardrop' still sends shivers down the spine and 'Inertia Creeps' is a nightmarish trip-hop groove. The first half contains the strongest songs, losing its way slightly half-way through, with two versions of 'Exchange' being unnecessary. The follow-up '100th Window' was an inferior photocopy of 'Mezzanine', which makes you realise how on the game Massive Attack were with 'Mezzanine'.  
2 Marilyn Manson - 'Mechanical Animals' (Nothing/Interscope)
 
AA sophisticated and at times mature body of work, 'Mechanical Animals' surprises in the sheer strength of the songs. This is Marilyn Manson's modern day glam rock update of Ziggy Stardust. First single 'The Dope Show' drips with studied lethargy, hard rock stomper 'Rock Is Dead' sets the mood of the album with infectious choruses and mocking sarcasm, climaxing on the ludicrously catchy 'I Don't Like The Drugs (But The Drugs Like Me)' with singing strippers and a groove that would make Prince proud thrown in the mix. After winning over the rock crowd with 'Antichrist Superstar', the polished 'Mechanical Animals' was customised for mainstream acceptance, but failed to capture the public's imagination as some anticipated. Part of the reason is down to the shift in image away from shock-goth NIN industrial atmosphere towards glamorous Hollywood mocking, a move the majority of fans didn't feel the connection. Whereas 'Antichrist Superstar' was loaded with destructive rage, 'Little Horn' and '1996' barely keeping together as they rallied against the world, the Glam-Rock influenced 'Mechanical Animals' was a brave move during a year when rock music suffered a blip in creativity. Manson was canny during his career as the goth-rock of 2000's 'Holywood' returned to his dark-hearted ways in retaliation to 'Mechanical Animals' criticism. But based purely on the music, disregarding Manson's image, 'Mechanical Animals' is a very well rounded collection of songs.  
3 Mercury Rev - 'Deserter's Songs' (V2 Records)
 
The child-like wonder that resonates through 'Deserter's Songs' in Jonathan Donahue's voice will either be music to your ears or an irritating annoyance depending on your taste. But music this good simply cannot be ignored. The rich orchestral sounds in the beautiful compositions of 'Holes', 'Tonite It Shows', 'Opus 40' and especially 'Goddess On A Hiway' are heavenly works that use a diverse range of instruments without coming off as contrived.  
4 Smashing Pumpkins - 'Adore' (Virgin/Hut)
 
After a band release a statement as grand as Melon Collie during their career, the only path is down. So the low-key 'Adore' was perhaps a commercially bomb, confusing fans expectant of layers of guitars and over the top angst. The outcome effectively put the Pumpkin's career into irreversible decline. Yet despite the negativity, there are several fine moments ranging from Ava Adore's successful foray into "goth electronica" (I made-up a stupid pigeon hole). 'For Martha' has a surprisingly retrained performance from Billy Corgan, which constrast with the pop sensibilies of Ava Adore and Perfect. The most upbeat track Appels + Oranjes stand out like sore thumbs next which ruin the seamless and sombre flow. If only approx 20 minutes was edited from the excessive running time, we would have an album to rival Alice In Chains' Jar Of Flies. What's left is a deeply flawed but fascinating document of a band in personal disarray (deaths, sackings and exhaustion).  
5 Beastie Boys - 'Hello Nasty' (Grand Royal/Capitol)
 
The Brooklyn rap collective who never take themselves too seriously pulled off a fine assortment of old-school rap on their fifth album, best illustrated on the entertaining 'Three MC's And One DJ', Latin beats on the surprisingly retained 'Song For Junior' and flat-out fun throughout 'Super Disco Breakin'' that it's hard to believe the trio were a crude bunch of snotty hardcore playing punks over a decade earlier. DJ Mixmaster Mike was on board, adding his deft turn-tabling skills, layering sonic collages over the raps. There's so much diversity, it's a challenge to digest in one sitting, especially at 22 tracks long. Obvious highlight 'Intergalactic' remains one the Beastie Boys finest singles, using irrelevant pop culture references and easy flowing rhymes whilst 'Body Movin' and 'The Negotiation Limerick File' are just as good in quality. There's even a dedication to black metallers Venon on yes you guessed it, 'Dedication'. Maybe the vast range of styles covered is too ambitious at time, but the Beastie's are one of the few recent groups to pull it off with relative ease.  
6 Pearl Jam - 'Yield' (Epic)
 
Pearl Jam reached their fifth album with 'Yield', settling into a comfortable lifestyle of making records for themselves and their dedicated audience. 'Yield' differs from other later-day PJ album with grander sounding songs, providing less breathing space for indulgent experimentation of 'Vitalogy' and 'No Code' moments (Bugs springs to mind). When the lo-fi sounds of 'Brain Of J' crank into life, it shows a band playing for the sheer fun of it, 'No Way', 'In Hiding', 'Given To Fly' and 'Faithfull' (sic) were admirable stabs at life-affirming hard rock. It was such a welcome return to the big rock songs of 'Ten' era that I immediately pronounced (to about 3 people) 'Yield' the best PJ album since 'Ten'. The initial hyperbole was helped by 'Yield' being easily digestible compared to surrounding PJ studio albums. Cutting to the chase, 'Yield' is not the best PJ album since 'Ten', more like another consistent recording that ranks higher than 'Binaural' and 'Riot Act', about the same quality as 'Vitalogy' and 'No Code'.  
7 Slayer - 'Diabolus In Musica'
 
Probably the only time Slayer "followed" a current musical trend, incorporating down-tuned guitars not too dissimilar to late nineties Soulfly or 'Far Beyond Driven' era Pantera. Having said that, it's still unmistakeably Slayer loaded with fury, trademark solos and dozens of shredding riffs from Kerry King. Up-tempo 'Death's Head' and 'Love To Hate' still intense compositions. Compared to classic era Slayer circa 1986-1990, 'Diabolus In Musica' lacks the thrash titan's drive and focus, and not revered as much as other Slayer albums by fans. Taken as individual segments and there are some fine songs in 'Perversions of Pain' and 'In the Name of God' which shows raw aggression. Unlike contemporaries Metallica, the modern day Slayer retains their bite with lyrical subject touching the usual serial killer and religious themes.  
8 PJ Harvey - 'Is This Desire?' (Island)
 
The electronic textures and low-key character of 'Is This Desire?' takes a while to digest, but listener patience is duly rewarded with 'A Perfect Day Elise' and 'The Garden', displaying all the attributes that made PJ Harvey previous works such intelligent works. In relation to PJ Harvey's back catalogue, 'Is This Desire?' would be the album purchased by fans last after absorbing the rest of her music. 'Is This Desire?' seems less interested in melody and song craft, more intent on using all the studio trickery to create industrial-lite textures and disjointed sounds. Stick with the album mind, and the beauty underneath the production starts to seep out, little fragments of inspiration appears fleetingly in the before mentioned 'A Perfect Day Elise' and elsewhere.  
8 Placebo - 'Without You I'm Nothing'
 
An impressive, grown-up sophomore effort containing a few slow burning dirges ('My Sweet Prince', 'Burger Queen') and energetic fare in 'Brick Shithouse' and 'You Don't Care About Us'. One of the most underrated tracks, the stirring 'Allergic (To All Thoughts Of Mother Earth)' added some substance to Placebo's repertoire, which caught the band at the peak of their popularity with creative juices running at optimum. Placebo's most memorable facet is frontman Brian Molko's androgynous look and distinctive vocals, adding some glamour and star attraction to an otherwise unremarkable band. That's not to discredit bassist Stefan Olsdal and drummer Steve Hewitt's contribution, but "without Molko, Placebo is nothing".  
10 Pitchshifter - 'www.pitchshifter.com' (Geffen)
 
Mixing rock guitars with electronic beats was not an innovative idea for Nottingham based Pitchshifter, combined punk attitude with thoroughly modern beats, which makes 'www.pitchshifter.com' come across as 'Fat Of The Land' minus the menacing atmosphere. Even guitarist Pitchshifter Jim Davis joined the Prodigy touring band at the time to boost the connection. More drum n'bass heavy and commercial than previous Pitchshifter releases, the cunningly website promoting titled album was jam packed with well-thought out songs, the most notable being ironic call-to-arms 'Genius', a statement of intent whose main hook was "if dysfunction is a function, then I must be some kind of geeennnniiiussss". Social commentary dominated the lyrics from mindless consumerism (Disposable) to national apathy (Second Hand) which summed up the mood of the nation. Offering free samples on the final track to aspiring musicians, Pitchshifter embraced the technological age to create a contemporary sounding rock album for the electronic generation.  

ALBUMS OF 1998 (# 11 - 40)

11. Refused - The Shape Of Punk To Come
12. System Of A Down - System Of A Down
13. Monster Magnet - Powertrip
14. Fat Boy Slim - You've Come A Long Way Baby
15. Air - Moon Safari
16. Korn - Follow The Leader
17. Garbage - Version 2.0
18. Scott Weiland - 12 Bar Blues
19. Manic Street Preachers - This Is My Truth, Tell Me Yours
20. Sonic Youth - A Thousand Leaves
21. Jeff Buckley - Sketches For (My Sweetheart The Drunk)
22. Everlast - Whitey Ford Sings The Blues
23. Semisonic - Feeling Strangely Fine
24. R.E.M. - Up
25. Therapy? - Semi-Detached
26. Drugstore - White Magic For Lovers
27. Beck - Mutations
28. Air - Moon Safari
29. Outkast - Aquemini
30. Ash - Nu-Clear Sounds
31. Propellerheads - Decksandrumsandrockandroll
32. Opeth - My Arms, Your Hearse
33. Pulp - This Is Hardcore
34. Sunny Day Real Estate - How It Feels To Be Something On
35. Jon Spencer Blues Explosion - Acme
36. Afghan Whigs - 1965
37. UNKLE - Psyance Fiction
38. Backyard Babies - Total 13
39. Eels - Electro-Shock Blues
40. Phish - The Story Of The Ghost

More Reviews:

Faith No More - Who Cares A Lot?
The farewell 'Who Cares A Lot?', contains all the greatest and most known songs from the very early funk of We Care A Lot to the straight Bee Gees cover version of I Started A Joke. In between are the seminal tracks off 'The Real Thing', namely 'Epic', 'Falling To Pieces' and 'From Out Of Nowhere'. The smooth and spacey 'Stripsearch' sits uncomfortably next to the menacing 'Digging The Grave' displaying the full versatility and warped genius of Faith No More. However, the real motivation for fans is the snazzy bonus CD highlighting the even weirder side. Cover versions are in abundance the classic 'Midnight Cowboy' and 'This Guys In Love With You' makes an appearance, as does an unreleased demo of 'Introduce Yourself'.

Hole - 'Celebrity Skin'
It wasn't until 1998 when the contrived Celebrity Skin came out, that anticipation levels reached its peak as the music industry was preparing for a huge selling Hole record. Even though the commercial songs including the poppy Malibu single, were geared towards the sophisticated pop market, Celebrity Skin still under performed with disappointing sale figures. The music itself was fine enough, in the same vein as Smashing Pumpkin's Adore or Marilyn Manson's Mechanical Animals (also sharing the same producer) albums; the slick sheen disguised the lack of actual songs. The title track came across as a brilliant take on Hollywood lifestyle from Love's perspective, Awful sounded like a modern update of a new-wave style Go-Go's track and the delicate Dying showed that Hole can still come up with the goods. Sadly these are essentially the high points on the album with only Use Once And Destroy and Hit So Hard maintaining the interest levels. It's during the second half that Celebrity Skin suffers in the filler department, as Heaven Tonight and Playing Your Song are enjoyable yet bland radio songs that are no different to something The Corrs or Belinda Carlisle could knock out in their sleep which disturbs me as The Corrs are one of the most infuriating bands in existence. Ultimately this is a good polished rock album that lacks the oomph and durability of Live Through This and the jagged rage and pure emotion of Pretty On The Inside that made Hole special in the first place. An album that tries too hard to please everyone by sinking into uninspired territory.

Feedback:

cbb1122@aol.com - 27 Mar 2003

How can you have a list of 1998's best rock albums without Phish's "The Story of the Ghost"? I realize the name Phish scares most mainstream rock fans, with images of the Grateful Dead, free-spirited concerts and widespread drug use in mind, but this album is truly spectacular. Trey Anastasio established himself as a legitimate force in the guitar world, and the band itself combined countless genres of music in one short, but sweet album. And the ongoing theme of the album's namesake throughout the work is intriguing and keeps the listener wanting more. "The Story of the Ghost" by Phish is easily one of the top rock albums of 1998.

Home Of Rock Reviews

 About Home